I certainly agree that they did not find it. Additionally that looks like cheating to us, but the only ones hurt is them.
We have found caches we could not log due to wet logs but if we did not touch it knowing it was the cache it was not a find for us.
It is your cache and your decision.
The call is yours....poppy
May those who love us, love us. And those that don't love us, may God turn their hearts; and if he doesn't turn their hearts may he turn their ankle so we may know them by their limp.... An Old Gaelic Blessing